MEMBER ZONE
October 16, 2026

FEAD severely questions ‘particular scrutiny’ imposed on exports of metal waste

A disproportionate rejection for metal waste

The ‘particular scrutiny’ imposed by the Commission’s draft list of non-OECD countries authorised to receive non-hazardous waste for recovery regarding ferrous and non-ferrous metal waste, has resulted in rejection of 16 out of 21 of the relevant requests. Only five (EU candidate) countries have been authorised in the draft to receive such waste.

This outcome is strongly questionable not only regarding the high rejection rate but also considering that metal waste is almost the sole rejected stream, only together with batteries, waste related to composite packagings, vessels and floating structures; all waste with considerably less well-established recycling routes and lower recovery rates. Moreover, the draft refers to the hazard profile and environmental concerns linked to a metal waste, which is clearly classified as non-hazardous, according to EU rules.

Export decisions must reflect actual environmental risk

The permissibility of exports should be based on the actual environmental risk posed by a waste stream and its treatment. The Commission proposes nevertheless to authorise exports of acidic waste, paint, dyes and inks to the same countries it assesses as not environmentally safe to receive – cleaner and significantly easier to recover – metal waste. This distinction is difficult to justify from a technical perspective. Differences in labour and environmental protection standards justify clear requirements and controls, but do not necessarily justify a blanket ban on a relatively unproblematic material stream.

The Waste Shipment Regulation already requires exporters to demonstrate, through independent audits of the receiving facilities, that the waste will be managed in an environmentally sound manner. A blanket exclusion of metal streams therefore duplicates existing safeguards and is disproportionate, in particular for clean, properly prepared green-listed scrap. Decisions should be based on the characteristics and contamination level of the specific waste, the treatment technology and the effectiveness of supervision in the receiving country and facility. It is striking that arguments used to reject countries include e.g. lack of information about the conditions for maintaining a stable shredder feed, separation techniques to increase recovery of secondary materials, or energy efficiency plans. These seem clear elements to be addressed in facility audits aimed at guaranteeing an environmentally sound management of the waste.

Waste shipment rules must not serve industrial policy

FEAD profoundly regrets the instrumentalisation made of the Waste Shipment Regulation to justify export restrictions. This is not only obvious from the assessment itself but even from publicly stated messages declaring that ‘we must keep the resources our industry needs in Europe’ and that ‘We chose to act first with the regulation on waste shipments’. The draft delegated act itself points in this direction: recital 32 announces that the Commission may consider separate measures on exports of waste, or of materials that have ceased to be waste, to address global imbalances, secure the supply of secondary materials and maintain the competitiveness of EU industry. These are industrial policy objectives, not the environmental and health protection objectives that the Waste Shipments Regulation is designed to pursue.

FEAD supports open markets and free trade. If the Commission’s objective is supporting European metals production, this must be done by looking at the entire value chain and not only at the final step. In fact, the European Commission does not seem to actually consider the sufficient availability of metal scrap on the EU market but the sufficient (financial) affordability of this material according to the views of the producing industry. This approach only focuses on one step of a value chain and fully undermines European recyclers and waste management operators, who are collecting, treating and providing the metal scrap.

Consequences for the European recycling value chain

In FEAD’s view, the resulting far-reaching restriction on exports of green-listed metal waste for recovery in non-OECD countries would, in particular, hamper the further development of the circular economy in the EU and globally. A substantial restriction of markets for recoverable waste could lead to oversupply within the Union, resulting in falling prices for such waste and for the recovered raw materials derived from it. This would have significant consequences for the economic conditions underpinning the circular economy. In particular, essential investments in expanding recovery capacity and in innovative processes aimed at improving the quality of recovered raw materials could become economically unviable and, as a result, fail to materialise. At the same time, as primary raw materials can continue to be traded globally, the recovered raw materials sector – and, by extension, the circular economy – risks being placed at an additional competitive disadvantage vis-à-vis the primary raw materials sector.

Metal scrap is not a homogeneous commodity, but comprises numerous grades, alloys and purity levels with different technical applications and markets. Most metal collected and recycled in Europe is already used within the EU; exports mainly concern grades for which European demand is insufficient. For example, while pure aluminium scrap circulates effectively within Europe, aluminium alloys generated exceed European demand, and their recycling rate would fall without export markets. It can therefore not be assumed that every tonne of scrap retained in the EU will be used in the EU: this depends on its composition and quality, the available technology and the demand for specific products. An export restriction will not automatically create outlets in Europe for the scrap that is today exported.

Finally, the effects would reach beyond direct exporters as revenue from the sale of prepared scrap finances its collection, transport, sorting and treatment. Metal scrap losing its value will also affect the economics for waste producers.

Demand keeps metals in Europe

In order to flourish and contribute to the EU’s environmental objectives, competitiveness and economic security, the European waste management industry requires strong and stable domestic demand of recycled materials. This is what FEAD has asked the European Commission to prioritise with the upcoming Circular Economy Act with concrete proposals. Without strong and stable domestic demand of recycled materials, the only consequence of restricting exports of those will be limiting market outlets, losing competitiveness and investment and innovation capacity. This, moreover, adds high risk of reciprocal trade restrictions, where the EU stands to lose due to its scarcity of (critical) raw materials. FEAD is opposed to exports of untreated waste and supports maximum collection, sorting and recycling within the EU, but stresses that a level playing field for the waste management industry vis-à-vis virgin producers requires comparable export rules. FEAD therefore urges the European Commission to reconsider its strategy with a holistic approach to ensure the competitiveness and sustainability of the entire European value chains, instead of solely focusing on one production step.

As clearly stated, FEAD strongly opposes one-sided export restrictions for metal waste. If any such measures would nevertheless be imposed, they must be accompanied by the right measures to ensure the competitiveness of the entire value chain. This means recycled content targets for European metal scrap to a degree that they ensure both the necessary and complete uptake from European recyclers as well as a market price, which can be negotiated indexed to the LME price. Moreover, additional measures, such as Green Public Procurement to ensure the uptake of European scrap but also rules that recognise the overall sustainable benefits of scrap – no sliding scale system for GHG savings – must be implemented. This is necessary to guarantee a level playing field between recyclers and metal producers, as well as to incentivise investments in advanced treatment technologies for metal recycling facilities.

FEAD’s requests to the Commission

Against this background, FEAD calls on the European Commission to reassess the scope of the list for metal waste and to authorise the streams for which compliance with the requirements of the Regulation has been documented. The Commission should give transparent reasons for each refusal, which must be different from what facility audits will assess, specify the information or action required for authorisation, and engage with the applicant countries so that additional evidence can be assessed and the list updated before 21 May 2027. The impact of the list should also be assessed at EU level, taking into account scrap grades, actual demand and treatment capacity, storage, employment and planned investments.


FEAD, the European Waste Management Association, represents the entire waste management value chain, from collection and sorting to recycling, energy recovery, and final disposal. It brings together the private waste and resource management industry across Europe through its 21 national member associations, which collectively represent over 3,000 companies. Together, the sector provides more than 500,000 local jobs and fuels €5 billion in investments into the economy every year. For more information, please contact: info@fead.be